TL;DR:Toptal screens its own network, introduces candidates within 24 hours and lets you trial a hire for up to two weeks without paying if it fails.
Upwork is an open marketplace where clients pay a 5% fee (10% on Business Plus) plus a contract initiation fee, and freelancers pay 0% to 15%.
Pick Toptal to hand off the screening, and Upwork to choose on price and read the profiles yourself.
Upwork’s Business Plus plan now sells what Toptal sells: a vetted top 1% of talent and a shortlist in under six hours. Its gross services volume (GSV) rose 174% year on year in Q2 2026, while Upwork’s total GSV fell 4%.
Toptal spent 2026 buying other vetted networks: QO Collective, Adeva, No Single Individual and Graphite.
Toptal or Upwork: which should you use?
Use Toptal when you need one senior contractor soon and cannot spend a week reading proposals. Its matchers pick the candidates, and a failed trial costs nothing.
Use Upwork when you have a defined task, a tight budget, or a freelancer already in mind. You do the screening, and in return you see each rate before you talk to anyone.
The table sets the two side by side on the terms each company publishes. A cell reads “not published” when neither the website nor the help pages give a figure. For the wider field, see our Toptal alternatives and Upwork alternatives pages.
Key takeaways
1Toptal says 90% of its clients hire the first candidate it introduces.
2Upwork kept 18.7% of marketplace spend as revenue in 2025, up from 15.4% in 2023.
3Toptal publishes no hourly rates. You get a quote on a call, and a $79 monthly subscription starts once you go ahead.
4Both now sell employment as well as contracts: Toptal through HireGlobal, Upwork through Lifted, whose EOR volume grew 29% in Q2 2026.
Toptal vs Upwork vs Second Talent for a US startup
If you are a US startup hiring one developer, these are the terms that decide the bill and the working day. Each figure comes from the company’s own pages, checked on October 12, 2026.
For a US startup
Toptal
Upwork
Second Talent
Published price
$79 a month subscription, plus a rate quoted per engagement
The freelancer’s rate plus a 5% client fee (3% for eligible US clients paying by bank); 10% on Business Plus
$25 to $39 an hour, billed monthly; $0 until you hire
One developer at 160 hours a month
Quoted on a call
At $50 an hour: $8,000 plus $240 to $400 in client fees
$3,999 to $5,999
Who screens
Toptal: fewer than 3% of applicants accepted
You do, from proposals and profiles
Second Talent: top 1% accepted
First candidates
Within 24 hours
As freelancers send proposals
A shortlist of 6 to 8 vetted profiles in 24 hours
If the hire does not work out
Trial of up to 2 weeks
No guarantee; you end the contract
90-day, one-time replacement
Overlap with US hours
Not stated
Depends on the freelancer’s location
4 to 6 hours a day
Toptal and Upwork both sell hours.
If the role is permanent, compare them with a dedicated engineer: Second Talent’s AI-native engineers from Asia start at $25 an hour, billed monthly, typically 50 to 70% below a US hire of the same seniority.
You, using reviews, badges and Uma, Upwork’s AI hiring agent
Who gets in
Fewer than 3% of applicants
Anyone who passes an ID and location check
Speed claim
Candidates within 24 hours; a hire in about 48 hours
Most clients hire within three days; Business Plus shortlist in under 6 hours
Trial
Up to two weeks, not billed if you are unhappy
No trial; escrow and payment protection
Client fees
$79 a month subscription
5% on Basic or 10% on Business Plus, plus a contract initiation fee
Freelancer fees
Not published
0% to 15% per contract
Rates
Not published; quoted on a call
Set by each freelancer
Size
35,000+ clients served since 2010
763,000 active clients (June 2026)
Employment option
HireGlobal employer of record
Lifted, for enterprise clients
What hiring managers and developers say
Reddit blocked every tool we tried on November 19, 2026, so these themes come from Trustpilot, Clutch and Hacker News threads we opened that day. The reviews section further down has the detail.
Upwork buyers stay for the talent and complain about the fees. In a May 2023 Hacker News thread, buyers said they find better freelancers there than elsewhere but disliked the 10% fee and the separate invoice per freelancer.
Upwork’s 2026 problem is noise. An agency owner in a September 2026 Ask HN thread described many brand-new accounts and used short Loom walkthroughs to find real candidates.
Toptal’s clients call it pricey but worth it. On Clutch, cost is its weakest score (4.5) against 4.8 for quality; one 2023 client ended a contract mainly over cost.
Both Trustpilot scores come mostly from freelancers. Toptal’s 4.8 and Upwork’s 4.2 on Trustpilot are written largely by talent, not by the companies hiring.
Our take
The fee you see is not the whole cost on either side. Upwork adds a 3% to 10% client fee and a contract initiation fee; freelancers price in their own 0% to 15%. Toptal adds a margin inside the quoted rate, which a former consultant on Hacker News said clients never see.
The two have moved toward each other. Upwork’s Business Plus sells a vetted top 1% and a shortlist in under six hours; Toptal now sells payroll through HireGlobal and AI data work through ExpertCrowd.
Screening time is the real price difference. On Upwork you read proposals; on Toptal you pay the margin to skip that. For one senior hire, that trade usually favours Toptal; for a defined small task, Upwork.
How Toptal screens: fewer than 3% get in
Toptal says it sees thousands of applications each month, and typically fewer than 3% are accepted. The biggest cut comes first.
Only 26.4% of applicants pass the English and personality interview, and only 7.4% clear the skill review that follows. Those rates come from Toptal’s screening process page.
After the skill review, the drop is small. Stage three is a live interview with a screener from the candidate’s own field, and 3.6% of all applicants get through it.
Stage four is a test project built on a real scenario, which takes one to three weeks.
The fifth stage has no end date. Members stay in the network only while their client work holds up.
For a client, the screening shows up as speed. Toptal’s client FAQ and developer hiring page make four claims about matching:
24 hrs
Time to first candidates, “in almost all cases”
48 hrs
Typical time to hire a developer
98%
Trials that turn into a hire
3
People you can trial per position
Source: toptal.com/faq and toptal.com/developers, read September 14, 2026.
Whose numbers these are. Every figure in this section is Toptal’s own. Toptal is privately held, so no outside auditor checks the pass rates or the trial-to-hire rate.
How Upwork filters: ID checks, badges and Expert-Vetted
Anyone can sell on Upwork once it has verified their identity and location. After that, quality signals come from the work: client reviews, work history and badges.
Upwork’s pricing page counts 18+ million freelancers across 180 countries, so filtering is the real job.
The badges run from Rising Talent to Top Rated and Top Rated Plus, which marks a record on large and long-term contracts. Expert-Vetted is the closest thing Upwork has to Toptal.
Upwork says those freelancers passed its own pre-screening and sit in its top 1%, but it does not publish a pass rate.
Upwork sells access to that tier through Business Plus. The plan has no subscription fee. It adds the Expert-Vetted filter, a shortlist from Uma in under six hours, and 60 invites per job instead of 30.
In return, the client fee doubles to 10% of each payment.
The open marketplace is not slow either. Upwork’s client guide says most clients hire within three days of posting a job. That figure leaves out the hours you spend reading proposals.
What each platform charges
The two companies price in opposite ways. Toptal shows you almost nothing before a call. Its pricing overview says clients pay a fixed weekly price for hourly, part-time or full-time work.
Upwork publishes its fees but not what the work will cost, because each freelancer sets a rate.
Toptal
$79 a month subscription, charged once you go ahead with matching
Cancel any time; you can ask for a refund if Toptal cannot provide talent
Rates quoted per engagement, not published
Invoices twice a month, on Net 10 terms
Upwork
5% client fee on Basic, 3% for eligible US bank payments
10% on Business Plus, 8% for eligible US bank payments
Contract initiation fee on every new Basic contract; on Business Plus, only fixed-price contracts of $100 or less
Freelancer fee of 0% to 15%, fixed for the life of the contract
Source: toptal.com/faq; upwork.com/pricing/client and Upwork Help, read September 14, 2026.
The Upwork client fee is simple to model. Upwork’s own pricing page says a $100 contract costs $105 on Basic and $110 on Business Plus, before the initiation fee.
The 3% bank rate needs a US account, $1,000 of spend in the past 12 months and on-time payments.
The freelancer fee matters to you as well, because freelancers price it in. Upwork’s help article gives the example: to take home $20 an hour after a 10% fee, a freelancer bills $22.22.
Upwork sets the fee per contract, “based on factors that help support a balanced and competitive environment”.
That variable fee is new. Upwork moved from tiered freelancer fees to a flat 10% in 2023, then switched new contracts to a 0% to 15% range in May 2025.
Contracts signed before May 2025 keep the flat 10%, according to Upwork’s FY2025 annual report.
Neither company publishes what a developer costs per hour. For market rates by role and region, our freelance developer rate index gives hourly rates for 61 stacks and roles across nine regions, set against US rates.
Rechecked November 19, 2026. Toptal’s FAQ still lists the $79 monthly subscription, and its pricing page a $0 recruiting fee and no termination costs. Upwork’s pricing page refused our automated requests that day, so the Upwork fees above are as read on September 14, 2026; check them on the page before you post a job. Clutch’s profile field puts Toptal at $100 to $149 an hour, which is Clutch’s estimate, not a Toptal price.
What happens when a hire does not work out
Toptal takes the first two weeks of risk. Each engagement starts with a trial of up to two weeks. If you are not satisfied, Toptal does not bill you, and it can start a second no-risk trial with another expert.
You can trial up to three candidates for the same position.
Upwork has no trial. Its protection is about payment, not fit. On fixed-price work, money sits in escrow and releases at milestones you approve. Upwork bills hourly work to the client weekly.
If a client gets a refund, Upwork returns the freelancer’s service fee on that amount. Ending a contract that is not working is up to you.
That changes who pays for a bad first week. On Toptal, a poor match during the trial costs you time but no invoice. On Upwork, you pay for approved work until you end the contract.
Upwork’s business: fewer clients, more spend each
Upwork is public and reports to the SEC. In 2025 it handled $4.03 billion of GSV and booked $787.8 million of revenue. Active clients fell 6% to 785,000, while GSV per active client rose 7% to $5,129, according to its FY2025 Form 10-K.
The filing notes that client counts come from Upwork’s internal tools and no third party verifies them.
The pattern held into 2026. By June 30, active clients were down to 763,000, and GSV per active client hit a record $5,230. Upwork’s Q2 2026 results guide full-year revenue to $730 million to $750 million, below the 2025 total.
Its CEO described the shift in the same release:
“While lower-complexity work continues to shift toward automation, we are increasingly seeing what is emerging in its place: growing demand for high-value AI talent, more complex projects, and new categories of work across SMB and Enterprise.”
Hayden Brown, CEO of Upwork, Q2 2026 results, August 10, 2026
Upwork also keeps more of each dollar that passes through the marketplace. The 10-K credits growth in ads and monetization products, which include Connects, the tokens freelancers buy to send proposals.
GSV from AI-related work grew more than 22% in Q2 2026.
Business Plus is also where Upwork now finds new buyers. In Q2 2026, 38% of Business Plus active clients had made their first Upwork purchase on the plan.
Toptal’s business: private, and buying networks
Toptal LLC dates from November 2010, and Taso Du Val is its CEO. It publishes no revenue. Its about page gives running totals instead, all as of 2025:
Clients servedSince 2010
35,000+
Up from 25,000+ in 2023
ApplicationsSince 2010
3,600,000+
Up from 1,600,000+ in 2021
EngagementsSince 2010
91,000+
Talent placed with a client
Network reach2025
155+
Countries where its talent lives
These counts are cumulative, so they only rise. Do not set them against Upwork’s active client number. Upwork counts a client who spent anything in the past 12 months. Toptal counts all clients since 2010.
Toptal is growing by acquisition. In 2026 it bought QO Collective for management consultants, Adeva for developers, No Single Individual for branding and creative work, and Graphite for finance and strategy consultants.
In 2025 it added sales experts and launched HireGlobal for global payroll and compliance.
Contractor or employee: both now sell both
Freelancers on Toptal and Upwork work as contractors. Both companies now also sell the employment layer.
HireGlobal offers employer of record contracts and says Toptal has processed more than $5 billion in payroll and payments across 180+ countries. Its “virtual employer of record” model carries $1 million of indemnification per worker.
Upwork does it through Lifted, its enterprise arm. Lifted bought Ascen in 2025 to strengthen its employer of record offering, and GSV from that offering rose 29% year on year in Q2 2026.
If you are weighing a contractor against an employee in a specific country, our employer of record guides cover the rules market by market.
Reviews: Toptal and Upwork side by side
Scores below were read on November 19, 2026. Upwork’s review count is close to seven times Toptal’s, and both sets come mainly from freelancers.
Trustpilot
Clutch
Who writes the reviews
Toptal
4.8 on Trustpilot (2,586 reviews, 491 in the last 12 months)
4.8 on Clutch (53 client reviews; cost scores lowest at 4.5)
Mostly freelancers on Trustpilot; clients on Clutch
Upwork
4.2 on Trustpilot (17,187 reviews, 7,117 in the last 12 months)
Not checked
Mostly freelancers; 16% one-star
What users say about Toptal
Toptal’s two review sites tell different stories because different people write them. On Trustpilot, 89% of the 2,586 reviews are five stars and 4% are one star.
Nine of the ten newest reviews on November 19, 2026 read as written by Toptal freelancers praising the matching team, steady clients and on-time pay.
The one client among them said Toptal quickly found two people for a website and sales funnel migration.
Clients review Toptal on Clutch, where it scores 4.8 from 53 reviews. Quality, schedule and willingness to refer all sit at 4.8; cost is the weakest score at 4.5. The comments match the number.
A blockchain client in April 2024 wrote: “They were pricey, but it was definitely worth it.”
A DevOps staffing client spending about $300,000 a year (November 2023) called the rates higher than competitors and ended one contract mainly over cost.
A nonprofit client in January 2024 said the service is not cheap but worth the investment.
Hacker News adds the talent side. In a January 2023 thread, a former Toptal consultant said the consultant sets the rate and Toptal adds a margin the client pays without seeing it, and that recruiters pushed back when he raised his rate.
In a February 2022 Ask HN thread, a client said Toptal’s minimum quote for a PHP developer was about $80 an hour, with quotes seen up to $140, and that the work was good; another commenter, who had both hired and applied, called Toptal expensive with a few weak people slipping through.
Applicants in an August 2016 thread put the screening at roughly 40 hours of their own time.
What users say about Upwork
Upwork has the largest review record here and the most mixed. Trustpilot shows 4.2 from 17,187 reviews, 7,117 of them in the last 12 months; 72% are five stars and 16% one star.
The newest reviews on November 19, 2026 come mostly from freelancers.
They praise long-term clients and having contracts and payments in one system, and complain about the cost of Connects, a freelancer fee one reviewer says rose from 10% to 15%, and job posts that never lead to a hire.
One client said their account was closed after tipping a tutor, with no appeal.
Buyers on Hacker News like the talent more than the platform. In the May 2023 thread on Upwork’s fee change, one buyer described good results bringing in fractional development, DevOps and design skills, despite many unreliable providers.
Another said they keep returning because they find better freelancers on Upwork than elsewhere, but that a freelancer working two weeks spends a whole day just covering the fee.
The 2026 complaint is noise. In a September 2026 Ask HN thread, an agency owner who hires through Upwork said he still sees many brand-new accounts, and that short Loom videos walking through the task helped him find real candidates.
Another client in the thread said they felt flooded from all sides.
What changed at Toptal and Upwork since 2023
Toptal: more networks, more products
The Wayback Machine returned errors for toptal.com on both of our tries on November 19, 2026, so this history comes from Toptal’s own about page, which publishes its totals year by year.
Between 2023 and 2025, clients served rose from 25,000+ to 35,000+, engagements from 68,000+ to 91,000+, applications from 2.7 million+ to 3.6 million+, and the countries its talent lives in from 145+ to 155+.
The product changed more than the numbers. Toptal launched HireGlobal for payroll and employment in 2025, then bought four talent networks in 2026.
The same page now lists two AI businesses: ExpertCrowd, which sells RLHF, data labeling and model evaluation powered by Toptal’s network, and Toptal AI, described as a full-stack AI services company.
Its freelance hiring product, the $79 subscription and the two-week trial are unchanged.
Upwork: higher take, fewer and bigger clients
The Wayback Machine returned errors for upwork.com on both of our tries on November 19, 2026, so this history comes from Upwork’s filings and help pages.
In May 2023, Upwork moved freelancers from a tiered fee (20%, 10% and 5% by lifetime billing per client) to a flat 10%, the change discussed in the Hacker News thread above. In May 2025 new contracts moved to a variable fee of 0% to 15%.
Over the same years Upwork kept a larger share of each dollar: its take rate rose from 15.4% in 2023 to 18.7% in 2025.
By 2026 it was also selling Business Plus with an Expert-Vetted top 1% tier, Uma as an AI hiring agent, and employer of record through Lifted, which bought Ascen in 2025.
Active clients fell while spend per client rose, so the marketplace of 2026 serves fewer, larger buyers than the one of 2023.
Cost example: one senior developer for six months
Six months of full-time work is about 960 hours. Upwork rates are set by each freelancer, so the example uses $50 an hour, the same rate as the US startup table above. Toptal publishes no rate.
Six months, one senior developer
What you pay
What it rests on
Upwork Basic at $50 an hour
$49,440 to $50,400 plus initiation fees
$48,000 of work plus a 3% (US bank) to 5% client fee
Upwork Business Plus at $50 an hour
$51,840 to $52,800
$48,000 plus an 8% (US bank) to 10% client fee
Toptal
$474 in subscription fees plus the quoted rate
$79 a month for six months; talent rate given on a call
Toptal at Clutch’s listed range
$96,000 to $143,040
Clutch’s $100 to $149 an hour times 960 hours; not a Toptal quote
Second Talent
$23,994 to $35,994
$3,999 to $5,999 a month, all-in, including employment
The Upwork rows leave out the hours you spend screening proposals, and the Toptal rows leave out the trial, which costs nothing if the first match fails.
A senior developer on Upwork can bill well above $50 an hour; the arithmetic scales in a straight line.
Choose Toptal if, choose Upwork if
Choose Toptal if
You want someone else to screen and send names within 24 hours
You want a no-risk trial of up to two weeks, with up to three people
The hire is a senior contractor for months, not a task
You may need payroll or EOR later, through HireGlobal
Choose Upwork if
You have a defined task and want to see rates first
You are happy to read proposals and run your own tests
You want escrow on fixed-price milestones
The budget is small, or you already know the freelancer
By budget. Upwork shows every rate before you talk to anyone, so it wins when the budget is fixed and small. Toptal suits budgets that can absorb a premium for screening.
By speed. Toptal introduces candidates within 24 hours; Upwork says most clients hire within three days, and Business Plus promises a shortlist in under six hours.
By role. For senior developers, the deciding question is who screens. Toptal does it for you. Upwork’s Expert-Vetted tier does part of it, at a 10% fee.
By time zone. Both are global. On Upwork, check where each freelancer is based before you invite them; on Toptal, ask for your hours in the brief.
Other options worth a look
Arc.dev: published freelance rates and a one-off 20% fee for full-time hires.
Revelo: Latin American engineers on US hours at an all-in yearly rate.
Turing: once a Toptal rival, now an AI training data company.
How we checked. We have followed Toptal and Upwork since 2023 as a talent platform in the same market. Prices, guarantees and screening figures come from each company’s own pages, with the read date given where it matters; we rechecked them on November 19, 2026. Review scores were read on Trustpilot and Clutch the same day. Reddit blocked every tool we tried, so user discussion comes from Trustpilot, Clutch and Hacker News threads we opened. The Wayback Machine returned errors for toptal.com and upwork.com, so their histories use Toptal’s year-by-year totals and Upwork’s filings. We did not sign up for paid trials.
Full-time engineers in Asia with Second Talent
Toptal and Upwork both leave you with a contractor, or an EOR you set up yourself.
Second Talent vets engineers and employs them for you in nine Asian markets: Vietnam, the Philippines, Indonesia, Singapore, Malaysia, Thailand, Hong Kong, Taiwan and China.
The price is $25 to $39 USD an hour per engineer, billed monthly ($3,999 to $5,999 for 160 hours), all-in, covering sourcing, vetting and our managed EOR.
Our engineers pass four vetting stages: a technical assessment, an AI-native tooling check covering Claude Code, Cursor and Copilot, English at C1 or above, and a behavioral interview.
Search the talent directory yourself or send us a brief. We are engineering first, with a limited non-technical bench in design, sales development, data annotation and operations. Full terms are on our pricing page.
Toptal says the full process takes 3 to 8 weeks, and the test project alone runs one to three weeks. That time falls on the applicant, before you see anyone.
How does Toptal bill clients?
Toptal invoices twice a month on Net 10 terms. It accepts major credit cards, ACH, bank wires and PayPal.
Can I pay a freelancer I found elsewhere through Upwork?
Yes. On Business Plus, a direct contract with a freelancer you sourced off Upwork costs $49 a month per active contract.
Is Toptal or Upwork better for hiring developers?
Toptal is better when you want the screening done for you and a candidate within a day. Upwork is better when you know the task, want to choose on price and can review profiles yourself.
For a full-time developer, neither is built around a permanent hire.
What does Upwork charge clients?
Upwork’s pricing page lists a 5% marketplace fee on the Basic plan, 3% for eligible US clients who pay by bank account, and 10% on Business Plus (8% by bank). Contract initiation fees apply on some contracts.
What is Toptal’s revenue?
Toptal is private and publishes no revenue. Its about page gives running totals instead: 35,000+ clients and 91,000+ engagements by 2025. Upwork, which is public, booked $787.8 million of revenue in 2025.
Does Toptal offer discount codes or vouchers?
Toptal’s FAQ and pricing page list no discount codes or vouchers. The published costs are the $79 monthly subscription and the weekly rate you are quoted, with a $0 recruiting fee.
Elton Chan is the Co-Founder of Second Talent, a solution that connects global tech leaders with top-tier tech talent across Asia. He specializes in talent solutions and has led Second Talent’s rapid growth since 2024, helping scale its network to over 100,000 pre-vetted developers and earning industry recognition as the #1 in the Global Hiring category on G2.
A long-time entrepreneur with deep roots in digital transformation, Elton previously co-founded Branch8, a Y Combinator–backed e-commerce technology firm, and served as the Founding Chairman of HKEBA, a leading Asia-focused business association driving innovation, digital education, and cross-border collaboration.
His work bridges technology, talent, and business strategy to shape how companies scale in an increasingly remote and digital world.